Hi Mikee,
The price is in the average band, I would think, but is it for B&B / Half Board or room only?
Romanza - does have many good reviews - and I mean from lots of people I have met who stay there.
As a place to stay - is a great Hotel.
I wouldn't stay there myself, but "only" because I don't like the walk up the hill.
I prefer to stay somewhere on the flat! and just a few mins from the beach as we prefer that to a pool.
Fishing; No organised Trips for Fishing in S S, but check with Noula in San Stefanos Travel as she may know of one.
I have been going every year since 1983 and I often go out with Vassillis from the (Mini-Market) Now Margaritas Supermarket.
If it works out, i.e. calm weather etc, I meet him at 07:00 and go out on his boat & help him put his nets out, & bring in yesterdays!
But this kind of fishing may not suit you, however he does have rods and used to hire them out.
Basically, you need to have a chat with him if that kind of fishing "rocks your boat", make friends and he will invite you if you express an interest.
Also - ask Nikkos (Bar Manager), in the Thomas Bay Hotel if his Dad Theo still has a boat.
Theo probably still does and we hired him for the day a few times over the years, but quite a long time ago now to be fair.
We did our own "Islands excursions" before they did them commercially, with Theo and his knowledge is extensive.
If he still does it, I am sure he would take you Rod fishing for a very fair price!
Good Luck
Tony